Learn more about homes in Shelter Island, NY

About Shelter Island, NY

Located just minutes from the Hamptons and hours from Manhattan, this lovely island offers the best of the Long Island shoreline. Easy access and fabulous real estate; country restaurants featuring local produce, art galleries and antique stores galore.

Shelter Island Home inventory breakdown by property type

Of the 9 homes for sale in Shelter Island, the breakdown of property types is as follows:
78% Single Family and 22% Rental.

78% Single Family
22% Rental

Area details, home facts and figures

Homes for sale 9
Average Home Size 3,067 ft² / 285 m²
Price Range ($40,000 - $3,995,000)

Weather in Shelter Island

The average high temperatures in Shelter Island range from 38 in January to 81 in July

Average home income in Shelter Island

The average household income of a Shelter Island resident is $110,366 with an average home value of $839,322

Population of Shelter Island

Shelter Island has 962 residents.

Home ownership in Shelter Island

The average level of home ownership in Shelter Island is 75%.

Education breakdown of Shelter Island

Education levels of residents of Shelter Island include: highschool 20%, associate 8%, bachelor 14%, graduate 23%.

Households in Shelter Island

Shelter Island has 438 homes, built on average 46 years ago.

Information from in and around Shelter Island...

You are Viewing 1 to 9 of 9 homes for sale in Shelter Island. These homes are comprised of Single Family and Rental. The average list price of these property results is 962,888. Prices are shown as US Dollar. For more information on these homes for sale in Shelter Island please contact our member brokerages to schedule a showing or view an open house.

The 9 homes for sale in Shelter Island, NY are represented by 2 member brokerages serving the Shelter Island area. Member brokerages representing the 9 homes include Brown Harris Stevens Residential Sales, LLC/The Hamptons and Halstead Real Estate NY/NJ.