Learn more about homes in Montauk, NY

Welcome to Montauk, NY

Montauk is a hamlet within the town of East Hampton, located on the south shore of Long Island in Suffolk County, NY. When the first generations of European settlers arrived on Long Island, they leased the area of Montauk from the native Algonquian Indians as pasture land for their livestock. In 1686, East Hampton settlers purchased the land outright, and Montauk became home to the first cattle ranch in the United States. In the summer months, more than 1500 cattle from all over Long Island were driven into the area from as far as 70 miles away. At the turn of the 18th century, there were three permanent residences; First House, Second House, and Third House, named so for the order in which someone would pass them when riding out. After the state of New York joined the Union, President George Washington established a Coast Guard station in Montauk with the construction of the well known Montauk Lighthouse in 1797. Until the late 19th century, the lighthouse and three residences were the only structures in Montauk. As New York City began to grow in the 19th century, so did the East End of Long Island. In the early 1900’s, elite New Yorkers began to purchase land in Montauk on which to build summer homes, and thus began Montauk’s tourist industry. The region’s natural beauty—its acres of undisturbed land, miles of white sandy beaches, and rolling surf of the Atlantic Ocean—still attract thousands of people from all over the world today. Montauk has six state parks that offer everything from hiking to camping to leisurely picnicking. Montauk is also a major destination for commercial and recreational fishermen, the Montauk Harbors being the busiest in the state of New York.

Being at the easternmost tip of Long Island, Montauk playfully advertises itself as “the last resort,” and takes great pride in its laid back beachy atmosphere. Perhaps it is this aspect that brings not only tourists, but many new residents to the community. Currently, the year-round population of Montauk is at approximately 4,000. The people of Montauk take great care to preserve the town’s charm and character by not allowing the area to become overly-commercialized. East Hampton town zoning regulations prevent chain stores from taking over; in fact, there are no chain restaurants, retail stores, or hotels in Montauk, which means that there’s always something special around every corner in Montauk.

Montauk Home inventory breakdown by property type

Of the 16 homes for sale in Montauk, the breakdown of property types is as follows:
50% Residential, 38% Rental, 6% Single Family and 6% Other.

50% Residential
38% Rental
6% Other

Area details, home facts and figures

Homes for sale 16
Average Home Size 2,350 ft² / 218 m²
Price Range ($719,000 - $7,999,000)

Weather in Montauk

The average high temperatures in Montauk range from 38 in January to 79 in July

Average home income in Montauk

The average household income of a Montauk resident is $116,100 with an average home value of $818,072

Population of Montauk

Montauk has 3,424 residents.

Home ownership in Montauk

The average level of home ownership in Montauk is 72%.

Education breakdown of Montauk

Education levels of residents of Montauk include: highschool 33%, associate 6%, bachelor 19%, graduate 15%.

Households in Montauk

Montauk has 1,465 homes, built on average 39 years ago.

Information from in and around Montauk...

You are Viewing 1 to 16 of 16 homes for sale in Montauk. These homes are comprised of Residential, Rental, Single Family and Other. The average list price of these property results is 1,808,387. Prices are displayed as US Dollar. For more information on these homes for sale in Montauk please contact our member brokerages to schedule a showing or view an open house.

The 16 homes for sale in Montauk, NY are represented by 2 member brokerages serving the Montauk area. Member brokerages representing the 16 homes include Brown Harris Stevens Residential Sales, LLC and Halstead Property, LLC.